Prima Facie Defamatory Passages Can’t Justify Ban On Total Guide: Delhi Excessive Court docket Lifts Blanket Injunction In opposition to HarperCollins’ “Sure Man” Guide On Rana Kapoor

The Delhi Excessive Court docket has held {that a} discovering that sure passages in a literary work are prima facie defamatory doesn’t imply that publication of the work as an entire should be interdicted. It held that interim reduction should bear an affordable relationship to the character and extent of the prima facie harm. It added {that a} complete ban pending trial tilts the steadiness in the direction of the suitable to popularity with out addressing the suitable to freedom of speech and expression.

The Court docket modified the trial courtroom’s order restraining HarperCollins and writer Pavan Chand Lall from promoting, distributing or circulating “Sure Man: The Untold Story of Rana Kapoor”. It confined the restraint to the parts containing the 4 statements discovered prima facie defamatory or derogatory. It declined to intrude with these findings, holding that the defences of justification and truthful remark weren’t so clearly established as to render Kapoor’s declare sure to fail at trial.

The guide was printed on December 22, 2020 and issues the life and profession of Rana Kapoor, co-founder and former MD and CEO of Sure Financial institution, within the context of the financial institution’s rise and subsequent disaster. Kapoor had sued for everlasting injunction, alleging that the guide and two associated articles and an interview had been defamatory and infringed his popularity, privateness, character and truthful trial rights. Lall was proceeded in opposition to ex parte and by order dated July 10, 2024, the District Choose, Tis Hazari Courts discovered 4 Statements defamatory and derogatory, and didn’t discover the remaining statements objectionable. It nonetheless restrained the guide in its entirety throughout the pendency of the go well with, and directed removing of the articles and interview. It discovered that the guide wouldn’t prejudice the legal proceedings in opposition to Kapoor. HarperCollins and Lall appealed.

The courtroom famous that the guide had remained in circulation since December 2020 and that Kapoor was attributed data of it in January 2022, whereas holding that his incarceration didn’t disentitle him from reduction. Counting on Swami Ramdev v. Juggernaut Books Pvt. Ltd. (2018), it held that the trial courtroom had overlooked the necessity to steadiness the rival rights. The Court docket additionally noticed that Lall, having chosen to not seem earlier than the trial courtroom, couldn’t have factual issues examined for the primary time in attraction. It held, nevertheless, that his non-appearance couldn’t convert findings on 4 statements right into a discovering that the entire guide was defamatory.

Learn judgement right here.

Delhi Excessive Court docket Restrains US Copyright Proceedings In opposition to TV Immediately Over Climate Footage

The Delhi Excessive Court docket, in T.V. Immediately Community Restricted v. World Climate Productions LLC , restrained US-based World Climate Productions LLC and different defendants from pursuing copyright infringement proceedings in opposition to TV Immediately Community earlier than the US District Court docket for the Northern District of California over the usage of climate footage in 42 information movies. Justice Tejas Karia noticed that the movies had been conceived, edited and uploaded in India for Indian audiences, with the related proof and personnel additionally situated in India, making Indian courts the suitable discussion board. The Court docket additional held, prima facie, that the jurisdiction declaration underneath YouTube’s DMCA counter-notification course of was a standard-form requirement and didn’t quantity to a negotiated settlement to submit the dispute to US jurisdiction. It additionally noticed that temporary extracts of climate footage integrated into information reporting, narration and commentary could qualify as truthful dealing underneath Part 52(1)(a)(iii) of the Copyright Act, 1957, and will appeal to the doctrine of de minimis use. The Court docket discovered the parallel US proceedings prima facie vexatious and oppressive, noting the potential of conflicting selections, whereas clarifying that its observations had been preliminary and never a last willpower of the copyright dispute.

Learn judgement right here

Kerala movie our bodies object to CBFC’s new diktat on titles, name it pointless enlargement of powers and warn authorized motion

The Central Board of Movie Certification (CBFC) lately issued new pointers and an advisory for filmmakers submitting their movies for certification. One of many guidelines within the new diktat was that movies’ launch dates and titles should not be thought of last, no matter the promotional run. The Kerala Movie Chamber of Commerce and the Movie Producers Affiliation objected to this, calling it an pointless enlargement of the board’s powers.

Anil Thomas, president of the Kerala Movie Chamber of Commerce, identified that having a set title is important for a number of actions surrounding the movie. Every time a movie title is registered with them, they seek the advice of different chambers to see whether or not the title is already used or registered elsewhere. In addition they be sure that titles are authorised solely after correct screening to rule out something offensive or obscene.

B Ragesh, president of the Movie Producers Affiliation, additionally identified {that a} title is important to the movie’s business id. He exclaimed that the whole lot related to a movie is marketed underneath that identify and gave a hypothetical state of affairs of doing all of the promotions and publicity underneath that identify, solely to be instructed two days earlier than its launch that one has to alter the title.

The movie our bodies now plan to satisfy the state cultural affairs minister, PC Vishnunadh, to lift the problem and search a decision. They’re additionally reportedly contemplating authorized motion if their issues stay unaddressed.

Ramayana makers subject stern warning over leaked clips, threaten legal motion and contempt proceedings in opposition to offenders

The makers of Ramayana: Half 1 or as it’s internationally known as Ramayana: Rise of a Legend, have issued a powerful warning in opposition to folks recording the movie inside theatres and sharing clips on-line. With the movie working in cinemas since November 5, the crew has raised issues over unauthorised footage being circulated on social media and messaging platforms. They’ve now made it clear that anybody concerned in recording or distributing such content material might face authorized penalties.

The movie’s official social media handles shared a authorized discover addressing the unauthorised recording and sharing of its footage. The discover additionally refers to 2 latest Bombay Excessive Court docket orders, dated November 2 and November 6, 2026, which limit folks from recording or sharing the movie with out permission. The makers have additionally identified that such actions usually are not restricted to copyright violations and will invite legal expenses. The crew has additionally requested individuals who have already uploaded footage from the movie to take it down instantly.

NCPCR holds last consultations on pointers for on-line security of kids

The Nationwide Fee for Safety of Youngster Rights on 12th November, 2026 held a last stakeholder assembly with representatives of social media and on-line gaming platforms as a part of its initiative to formulate complete pointers on accountable, protected and age-appropriate use of social media by kids.

The assembly targeted on reviewing the present youngster security measures adopted by digital platforms and deliberating upon the suggestions contained within the Youngster Security Implementation Matrix.

The individuals shared particulars of measures already applied, future plans for implementation and different strategies. In addition they made shows highlighting their present youngster security measures, consciousness initiatives for youngsters, dad and mom and caregivers, and plans to additional strengthen on-line security, the assertion mentioned.

The initiative assumes significance amid growing use of digital platforms by kids and issues over their publicity to dangerous and age-inappropriate content material, cyberbullying, on-line grooming, Youngster Sexual Exploitation and Abuse Materials (CSEAM), privateness violations and different types of on-line exploitation.

These inputs had been examined and consolidated right into a Youngster Security Implementation Matrix. The matrix included ideas like security by design, age assurance and age-appropriate expertise, youngster knowledge safety, CSEAM detection and enforcement, anti-addictive design and digital wellbeing, reporting and time-bound redressal, empowerment of kids and oldsters, and so on., the assertion mentioned.

Saregama sees AI boosting effectivity, however vows motion in opposition to unlicensed use of its music

Music label Saregama India sees synthetic intelligence (AI) as a long-term alternative to scale back prices and speed up time to market, however will proceed to combat the unlicensed use of its music catalogue, the corporate’s MD Vikram Mehra mentioned.

Chatting with analysts Mehra mentioned the corporate helps licensed innovation and is incorporating safeguards in opposition to dilution of rights and potential fraud into all its new digital licensing agreements.

For catalogue homeowners, the extra quick concern is the unauthorised use of their songs in AI-generated covers and remakes, relatively than competitors from AI-generated authentic music, Mehra mentioned. The corporate can also be proactively participating with AI creators to discover alternatives to personal and distribute AI variations of its fashionable songs, he added.

He cited Common’s name for AI-generated filler content material to be paid lower than human-created music, and Spotify’s efforts to develop licensed remix and canopy options with the consent, credit score and compensation of rights holders.

FWICE urges Kailash Kher and Jaspinder Narula to withdraw from live shows that includes Pakistani singers

Instagram posts asserting Kailash Kher and Jaspinder Narula’s performances alongside Pakistani singers have drawn criticism from the Federation of Western India Cine Workers (FWICE).

The affiliation has written to the singers and authorities authorities, urging them to rethink their participation. Whereas Kher is scheduled to carry out with Abida Parveen in Dubai, Jaspinder is slated to share the stage with Ustad Ghulam Ali Khan and Aamir Ghulam Ali in North America between November and December.

Ashoke Pandit, President of the Indian Movie and Tv Administrators’ Affiliation (IFTDA) and Chief Advisor to FWICE, confused that nationwide pursuits should take priority over business engagements.

Ashok Dubey, Common Secretary of FWICE, questioned the singers’ resolution to just accept the engagements for business causes and known as for presidency pointers to stop related situations.

Elvis Presley, Eminem music rights holders sue Suno over alleged copyright infringement

Music rights holders related to Elvis Presley and Eminem have filed separate copyright infringement lawsuits in opposition to AI music generator Suno in a California federal courtroom, alleging that the platform used their music with out authorisation to develop its expertise and produce AI-generated tracks.

The 2 circumstances had been filed within the US District Court docket for the Northern District of California. Whereas the Presley rights holders have additionally accused Suno of unlawfully exploiting the singer’s id, Eminem’s music writer Eight Mile Fashion has alleged that the platform permits customers to generate music and lyrics resembling the rapper’s copyrighted recordings.

The Presley lawsuit entails entities together with Genuine Manufacturers Group and Raleigh Music Publishing. The plaintiffs alleged that Suno’s expertise permits customers to create music resembling Presley’s distinctive singing voice with out acquiring the required permissions.

They’ve additionally invoked Tennessee’s Making certain Likeness Voice and Picture Safety Act, generally generally known as the ELVIS Act. Launched in 2024, the laws seeks to guard artists in opposition to unauthorised AI-generated use of their names, voices, pictures and likenesses.

In a separate lawsuit, Eight Mile Fashion, which controls tons of of Eminem recordings, together with ‘Lose Your self’, ‘With out Me’ and ‘The Actual Slim Shady’, accused Suno of copyright infringement. The writer alleged that the platform permits customers to supply tracks and lyrics that replicate components of Eminem’s work. The rapper will not be personally named as a participant within the lawsuit.

The authorized representatives of the 2 teams argued that Suno has commercially benefited from artists’ artistic work and identities with out securing the required licences.

Responding to the allegations, a Suno spokesperson mentioned the corporate’s goal was to allow the creation of authentic music relatively than capitalise on artists’ identities. The corporate mentioned it doesn’t allow customers to request particular artists or songs and makes use of exterior service suppliers to look at uploaded audio and lyrics for potential copyright violations. It added that it will proceed to strengthen its safeguards, the report added.

The newest lawsuits add to a rising checklist of authorized challenges confronting Suno over its use of copyrighted music. Warner Music Group, Common Music Group and Sony Music Leisure had beforehand taken authorized motion in opposition to the AI music firm over its coaching practices. Warner Music Group subsequently settled its dispute with Suno in November 2025. Common Music Group and Sony Music, nevertheless, proceed to pursue their circumstances.